The Art-Music Forum
August 04, 2021, 08:03:47 am
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: A place to discover and discuss a wide range of composers and music (both familiar and forgotten), recordings, broadcasts, books and art. Register, contribute and explore!
  Home Help Search Gallery Staff List Login Register  

  Show Posts
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 11
1  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Maliszewski Symphonic Works on: July 29, 2021, 09:09:16 am
although I do encourage you to purchase it (I bought it on iTunes) to encourage companies to
record these rare works.

Yes indeed, that's one of the reasons why I always buy the CDs.
2  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Maliszewski Symphonic Works on: July 28, 2021, 09:25:08 pm
I think it is a good idea just to wait a bit. This is still a brandnew release, and often it just takes a while until the physical CDs are available worldwide. This even holds with well-known labels: for instance, I already noted in the past that new CDs from British labels may need one month or so until you can buy them in Germany. As for the Maliszewski set, on the Dux website it is listed as a release in CD format, so that I do believe that sooner or later, everybody will get a chance to buy a physical copy (I also plan to do so).
3  DOWNLOADS ARRANGED BY NATIONALITY / Downloads: discussion without links should be posted here, for the access of both members and non-members alike / Re: British and Irish Music on: April 11, 2021, 08:00:34 am
Maris already mentioned the most important facts, but for completeness, I should maybe recall an older discussion about this collection:,7100.0.html
Miklos's collection was just vast for sure. I also had the pleasure to exchange quite some stuff with him in his late years. In fact, Miklos still had a lot more, since all the tapes he had have not even been included by the archive guys.
4  MEMBERS' CORNER / Miscellany / Re: National Orchestral Discography Pages prepared by Michael Herman on: March 31, 2021, 11:17:35 am

In fact, I don't think this is "our" Michael Herman. I had quite some personal contact with Mike over the years, and from this I know he was born in 1946 and lives in New York. From the few bits of information I can read from that obituary (without subscribing), this does not seem to be true for the guy in question (who must have been quite a bit older).
5  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Coming broadcasts and listen-later links / Re: Robin Milford Symphony No.2 on: March 29, 2021, 08:04:30 am
Sicmu's upload in the British and Irish Music folder from last November is still available:,506.0/msg,35926.html
That's in flac format (which is even lossless).
6  DOWNLOADS ARRANGED BY NATIONALITY / Downloads: discussion without links should be posted here, for the access of both members and non-members alike / Re: Turkmen Music on: November 08, 2020, 05:02:58 pm

many thanks for your upload indeed! I was not aware of that LP so far.

A few more details: your observation is completely right, the DSCH motif appears in the first movement indeed. Comparing the work to the two other (larger-scale) pieces by Halmamedov I know (namely his "Turkmenistan" symphonic pictures and his Symphony in E Minor, both from the 1960s), the piece certainly demonstrates an evolution in style. The earlier pieces are large colourful orchestral canvases with a strong national flavour, obviously supposed to be pictures of his native land, very enjoyable in fact.

The musical language of this string quartet is less (directly) national, more restrained and certainly shows Shostakovich's influence. I thought of Shostakovich's String Quartet No. 8 when listening to the beginning, and this is most certainly not mere coincidence: I read that the quartet also has the title "To the Memory of the Women and Children who were tortured in fascist Dungeons", while Shostakovich's quartet is of course decicated "to the victims of fascism and the war". So there seems to be a direct influence. Whether it was also written in memory of Shostakovich himself is an open question, though I think your hypothesis makes quite sense.

By the way, reading the English wikipedia article on Halmamedov, I see that he was born in 1938 rather than 1940 (commonly used so far) indeed, thanks for this (implicit) information. In today's Turkmenistan (where they now use a Latin alphabet) he is written Nury Halmämmedow.
7  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Alexander Mosolov: Symphony No. 5 & Harp Concerto on: November 07, 2020, 07:59:15 am
Can anyone explain the very strange title?

Paraphrasing the German article I linked above, the title is not that strange but actually quite describes what this work is above: in the beginning, a gathering of believers is described and a church service is begun, with some quotes of orthodox chants. However, after some time, it is disturbed by a second group of singers, calling for destruction. Sections of struggle (including fugal writing) follow, quoting revolutionary songs (the text mentions the Marseillaise, but if I recall correctly the Internationale and Whirlwinds of Danger / the Warszawianka are heard as well). Finally, both choirs join to celebrate the beginning of a new world without God. Of course, this has to be seen against the background of atheism being the Soviet "state religion", although at the same time it is worth noting that the piece was composed before Socialist Realism was established as the Soviet cultural doctrine. Probably it has to be seen as a late example of early Mosolov, continuing the line of his Iron Foundry and related works.
8  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Alexander Mosolov: Symphony No. 5 & Harp Concerto on: November 01, 2020, 11:12:43 am
Well, I did some more research on Mosolov and his symphonies and even if the picture does not fully clarify, a few more details have come up nevertheless. First, I realized that a while ago, Colin / Dundonnell also tried to compile a catalogue of Mosolov's orchestral music:,1459.0.html
As the three different lists of the symphonies demonstrate, it's really very difficult. At present, I believe the one compiled by Northern Flowers to be most reliable. If so, we should maybe consider the E Major symphony they recorded as No. 1 (with some care, of course).

None of these catalogues lists the "Antireligious Symphony", but this is certainly because it was only recently rediscovered. Reading the description of the German radio website I linked above, it gradually dawned me that I may even have this piece. Checking things, I found out that indeed, there is a piece in my collection just labeled "Symphonic Poem on Words by Mayakovsky and Sharov for Soprano, Mezzo Soprano, Choir and Orchestra" from 1931 which has to be the "Antireligious Symphony", even more so since it is performed by the forces the article suggests (Orpheus RSO / Kondrashev). It happens to be available online:
9  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Alexander Mosolov: Symphony No. 5 & Harp Concerto on: November 01, 2020, 09:02:48 am
Quite a while ago, maybe already ten years or so, I had a brief e-mail conversation with Martin Andernson where he mentioned his general interest in a cycle devoted to Peiko's orchestral works, however he also wrote that as always, it was a question of getting it financed. I am afraid things will not have changed meanwhile. Nevertheless, there might be some hope: Toccata have released a number of Soviet rarities in the past years, includig Peiko's piano music of course, but also some orchestral works by Shebalin, Weinberg and others, and they seem to be cooperating with Yuri Abdokov (who has been in charge of the liner notes for their latest Galynin CD, for instance), a pupil of Peiko and Boris Tchaikovsky. We will see.

Mosolov's "Antireligious Symphony" (a piece of 30 minutes with chorus, also labeled symphonic poem) has only recently been found in the archives of Soviet radio, it has been performed and apparently also recorded for the radio. Some information can be found here:
A German article (if necessary, I can provide some details).

As for Robert's suggestions, I should think about my own preferences in more detail. I would certainly also nominate some composers from the republics, i.e. Central Asia and the Caucasus region. As for Levitin, I only recently found out that there has been a 2 LP set with two of his symphonies by Melodiya. I already told Mike Herman and it now appears in his online catalogue (however, it mislabels the unnumbered "Days of War" Symphony as No. 1). Unfortunately, these LPs seem totally elusive.

10  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Alexander Mosolov: Symphony No. 5 & Harp Concerto on: October 31, 2020, 06:53:39 pm
Yes, I was also very surprised to come across this new CD, there had not been any real signs of a Mosolov revival before. As for the number of the E Major symphony, the liner notes of the Northern Flowers disc do not provide any details on this question and I currently believe the symphony just has no number. There is a catalogue in the German wikipedia on Mosolov's symphonies which I compiled years ago from all information I could gather, but it's far from certain that all details are correct since information is so sparse. Until now, I would not even have dared to bet that these scores actually exist. In any case, the symphonies listed are as follows:

  • Symphony Op. 20 (1927/28, lost)
  • Antireligious Symphony (1931)
  • Symphony in E Major (1944)
  • Symphony No. 2 in C Major (1946)
  • Symphony No. 3 in B flat Major "Song Symphony" (1949/50)
  • Symphony in C Major (1959/60)
  • Symphony No. 4 in A Minor (1959/60)
  • Symphony No. 5 in E Minor (1965)
  • Symphony No. 6 (until 1973, unfinished)

So the E Major symphony could be No. 1, but that's not quite clear. There might also be some possibility that the C Major and the A Minor symphonies (No. 4) could coindice, but who knows for sure...

Anyway, the composers you suggest would certainly be fine choices! I know that there have been plans to do a Peiko cycle on Toccata Classics, but it's a matter of finances and things seem rather difficult alas.
11  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Alexander Mosolov: Symphony No. 5 & Harp Concerto on: October 31, 2020, 12:06:28 pm
Naxos will release a new CD with Alexander Mosolov's Symphony No. 5 (1965) and his Harp Concerto (1939) later this year:

Mosolov is of course a classical example of a Soviet composer who had to change his style substantially by force (he was imprisoned for some time in the 1930s). His most famous piece is the short "Iron Foundry" from the unfinished ballet "Steel", a work of just a few minutes suggesting factory noise. In the 1920s and early 1930s, Mosolov's style was pretty radical and more and more atonal (as for instance in his First Piano Concerto). His works after the arrest are completely different and, as I have to say, not very convincing from all I heard so far. Northern Flowers brought out his Symphony in E Major (probably unnumbered) several years ago and in my view, it is a really weak piece, also weaker than "conformist" symphonies by other Soviet composers from those days. Nevertheless, I am happy to get another opportunity of trying some of Mosolov's later output now and will gladly buy this CD once it is available. There are still many open questions about his later works anyway, since the work lists available are partially contradictory, and possibly this release can shed some light on this.
12  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / Commercial recordings (vintage, new and forthcoming) / Re: Thomas Wilson Symphonies from Linn on: October 21, 2020, 04:49:18 pm
These are great news! I am very much looking forward to this CD, in particular for the Fifth, which is a great work distinguished by some kind of autumnal beauty.
13  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / YouTube performances / Re: Zaborov Symphony No. 1 on: October 12, 2020, 06:48:40 pm
The scans Gabriel spoke of can be accessed here:

I do not speak Russian myself, but nevertheless, as far as I understand this article does provide some biographic information on Zaborov (for instance, he seems to have been a student of Myaskovsky, he was violinist in the orchestra of the Bolshoi theatre from 1950 until 1985, from 1965 as concert master, there seems to be a list of ballets in which he played violin solos, he also had a son, Igor, who lived from 1952 until 2015 and played the violin and composed himself etc.). However, the article does not seem to mention the symphony. Anyway, many thanks to Gabriel for doing research on him! Smiley
14  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / YouTube performances / Re: Zaborov Symphony No. 1 on: September 08, 2020, 09:04:47 pm
No, I tried to find out a while ago but with no success. Even the date of the recording gives no clue because it was made after Zaborov's death if I remember correctly. Likewise, it is difficult to compile even some basic facts about Zaborov's life and work. The liner notes of the Svetlanov box just mention "Grigory Zaborov, a composer, violinist and concertmaster of the USSR Bolshoi Theatre", and that's basically already all we know about him.
15  MUSIC OF ALL ERAS / General musical discussion / Re: Obscure Russian/Soviet Piano Concertos on: September 08, 2020, 06:33:10 pm
Must be Evgeny Stikhin (* 1932). He does have an article in the Russian Wikipedia:Стихин,_Евгений_Михайлович
according to which his piano concerto was his graduation piece at conservatory. A lot of his works, including his piano concerto, can be found here:
Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 11
Powered by EzPortal
Bookmark this site! | Upgrade This Forum
SMF For Free - Create your own Forum

Powered by SMF | SMF © 2016, Simple Machines
Privacy Policy