|
guest128
Guest
|
 |
« on: March 14, 2019, 07:21:48 pm » |
|
Was Calyptorhynchus's response to my initial post clear and coherent to you yourself, Colin?
Take his first sentence:
"I contest your premises, any Symphony which is living and worth listening to is first-tier, other Symphonies are simply not worth listening to."
To me it's a mess, - not even a properly constructed sentence, and extremely unclear in meaning (at last to my mind). Is that MY (presumed) premise he's elaborating, or his own response to my supposed premise? I can't tell because the thought itself is incoherent to me, - it's components and word choices don't fit together in any understandable way.
Honestly, if someone called me "incoherent" here, - and in my long history of internet posting that would qualify as very tame - the first thing I would ask myself is "well, am I?". It might be true. I find forums like this one an ideal venue to sometimes test undeveloped ideas one might have (as often articulated in careless fashion), and use any responses/dialogue to modify, refine, abandon, renounce, or clarify the expression thereof as may be required. I APPRECIATE being provoked and criticized, so long as it's evidently exploratory and not gratuitous, - and thus now and then can appear insensitive to those who don't share the same mindset. Oh well.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
